Author's Latest Posts

Inflation is No Cure for Recession

Stock Market Held Hostage by the Dollar

Four Words Obama Will Never Say

Win Back the Party by Losing the Election

Inflation Will Make its Presence Known

The Debt vs. Interest Rate Conundrum

By Michael Pento | October 15, 2008 | 12:21 AM | 6 Comments

I've written before about the dramatic rise in fixed income rates that face investors in the very near future due to the funding issues associated with our entitlement programs coupled with the incalculable measures taken by the government in the past few weeks to stem the credit crisis. Those efforts ensure the amount of Treasury issuance will explode.

One of the major ramifications of having our national debt move above the $10 trillion mark is that the sustainability of the government, consumer spending and the economy rests on the continuation of artificially low interest rates. In fact, low rates that are the result of money printing have become our addiction.

In last week's commentary I pointed out that it now takes about 10 cents on every tax dollar collected just to pay the interest on the debt. As bad as that is, it is only because interest rates are at record lows that the debt service is still manageable.

The yield on the 10 year note as of this writing is 4.01 %. To illustrate how low that yield is in historical terms, the average constant yield on the ten year treasury going back 46 years is 7.04%. Keep in mind that this historically low yield exists at the same time consumer price inflation has increased by 5.4% over the last 12 months. Why are real yields negative while debt levels are soaring and the monetary base is growing at a 114% annual rate (you read that correctly-114% annualized in recent weeks)? Part of the answer has to do with investors' mistrust of holding debt that is not backed by the government.  But to get to the main reason why rates are so low you have to understand how the Fed Funds rate is set. When the Fed wants interest rates to fall, it prints money and purchases Treasuries as well as other bank assets. Printing money, however, increases its supply and is the definition of inflation.

 Can you see the conundrum? The Fed needs to constantly print money and expand the money supply in order to keep their target rate from rising. However, printing money is inflationary and demands that yields rise in order to provide a positive return for fixed income investors. The more they print the less the Federal Funds Rate will rise. And rates, especially on the short end of the yield curve, will most likely stay low-the Fed can only control the target rate for intra-bank lending, but free market short- and long-term rates also tend to be influenced by the central bank's target rate. Yet the further out on the yield curve you move, the more highly influenced rates are by inflation. It is important to stress that short-term rates have become much more important in recent years as banks and the government have increased the use of short term financing to fund  their operations.

The bottom line is this: debts at the public and private levels have risen to the point that in order to insure against default, interest rates must remain at an unnaturally low and negative real level. In order to achieve that artificial level, the Federal Reserve must continually inflate the money supply. How high would the overnight rate be if not for government operations? Well, one of the consequences of the credit crisis is that banks mistrust each other's assets and are reluctant to lend to one another. If market forces were allowed to operate, intra-bank lending rates would soar just as they did several weeks ago when the Effective Federal Funds rate hit 6%! Clearly the free market rate bears little resemblance to today's Fed Funds target rate of 1.5%.

However, inflation and low interest rates cannot coexist indefinitely. One will have to give way to the other. It is my view that government efforts to keep yields low across the curve will fail.  At some point, the yield curve will start to move sharply higher as short term rates remain relatively low and long term rates soar in response to inflation. It is at that juncture that market forces will prevail and send the economy into the greatly needed recession (or worse) that until this point was held in abeyance by our government. We can only hope this process happens sooner rather than later, as the longer it takes to occur the more severe the economic suffering will be.

www.deltaga.com

Comments (6)  |  Related Topics  » |

 
Not quite...

I agree with you completely that government intervention is distorting the markets and is planting the seeds for more trouble down the road, but I disagree with you about inflation, at the moment... $147 oil was what pushed up inflation... as of this article it's at $75, the numbers should improve dramatically in the coming months and early part of next year... Furthermore, the huge demand for dollars in the early part of this decade was what kept interest rates low. Unfortunately that demand is set to decline since dollars account for such a massive portion of global reserves after the debt binge of this decade. We are about to issue as much new treasury debt in the next 6 months as we did in the past 6+ years and I'm extremely worried that the Fed becomes the buyer of those treasuries via monetization. I'm still reluctant to buy gold though, because CBs have so much of it and can flood the market at any time. What do you think about silver Mike? I've read a lot of material saying that silver has served as an excellent monetary instrument as well.

Submitted by Bulleri on Wed, 2008/10/15 - 12:36pm » reply |
 
i'm very confused. You say

i'm very confused. You say you are not worried about inflation but you worry that the Fed will print money to buy Treasury debt. Short term deflation is the concern, but I try to think long term and get ahead of the curve. Long term, our debt will ensure that inflation will be our genuine concern. Oil has risen from $10 a barrel to $75 in just a few years. True it was higher a few months ago but thinking $75 oil is cheap is not historically accurate.

The demand for dollars was artificially caused from money printing by the Fed that allowed for a huge trade deficit which was then parked in US Treasuries. Inflation and low rates cannot exist for a protracted period of time. 

Silver is a good investment but I prefer gold. Silver is also an investment geared around the business cycle.  So it should underperform AU.

Submitted by Michael Pento on Wed, 2008/10/15 - 1:37pm » reply |
 
Sorry I sound equivocal...

I see inflation and deflation playing tug-of-war is all and it's quite a confusing environment... I like to think long-term as well (which is why I said 'at the moment') it's just become so murky though... Near-term I think inflation prospects have improved dramatically... I'm just worried long-term that our government will allow the dollar to enter the annals of failed paper currencies... I pray they don't... At least if we get a long bout of deflation, all the excesses will be purged out of the economy and we can start with a clean slate. If we get hyperinflation there will be nothing left.

Submitted by Bulleri on Wed, 2008/10/15 - 1:58pm » reply |
 
Now we are in perfect

Now we are in perfect agreemetn. I should also note that if your deflation scenario is allowed to play itself out (which I highly disagree will ever be allowed to happen) then the economy and the market will be headed lower for quite some time...much lower.

Submitted by Michael Pento on Wed, 2008/10/15 - 2:10pm » reply |
 
Well said. Government

Well said, Leonard. Government intervention in the fee markets is the cause of the problem. How can they fix the problem by doing more of the same things that got us here in the first place.

Submitted by Michael Pento on Wed, 2008/10/15 - 9:26am » reply |
 
Why is it that those in

Why is it that those in power don't see the building inflation pressures in our economy? we are going to have very high interest rates along with high inflation. When will people wake up and realize that government IS the problem not the solution

Submitted by leonardsimon on Wed, 2008/10/15 - 9:22am » reply |

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
More information about formatting options Captcha Image: you will need to recognize the text in it.
Please type in the letters/numbers that are shown in the image above.